COMMUNITY & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OFFICE
Burlington, Vermont  
  Brownfields | CDBG | VISTA | Site Map | CEDO Home | City Home
  Burlington A to Z   A   B   C   D   E   F   G   H   I   J   K   L   M   N   O   P   Q   R   S   T   U   V   W   X   Y   Z  
Housing Business Community Waterfront
 
  Moran Plant
    Public Process
    History and Past Ideas
    Site Data
    Current Activities
    Ideas and Comments
        Archive 1
        Archive 2
        Archive 3
        Archive 4
        Archive 5
        Archive 6
        Archive 7 Idea Night
        Archive 8
        Archive 9
        Archive 10
        Archive 11 Emails
        Archive 12
        Archive 13
        Archive 14
        Archive 15
        Archive 16
        Archive 17
        Archive 18
        Archive 19
        Archive 20
        Archive 21
        Archive 22
        Archive 23
        Archive 24
        Archive 25 Letters
 
  
  Google logo 
 
 
 

Your Ideas and Comments: Letters and Notes, May-June 2005

Thank you to all who have submitted ideas for the future of Moran!!

Waterfront dome

Waterfront Dome? Imagine, instead of the Moran plant, a waterfront dome. Rather, two half-domes. Pictures aid the imagination. One half is a smooth, white concrete shell, striking in any waterside park; the other is striking for its transparency, shown here as a geodesic design. The transparent half moves according to need. All-weather capability is more functional than a plain bandshell. The guiding purpose is open-air theatre and music. The solid half accommodates stage, wings and flies for ambitious theatre, albeit no rival to the Flynn. As for music: acoustic only! Nothing louder than a symphony orchestra. No amplified music on the waterfront, let alone a residential area; audiences of a few hundred, not thousands.

The neatest feature: come rain, the mobile half lowers to canopy position over the audience. Slightly larger than the other half, it both rises and revolves. This is an ellipsoidal dome; a spherical dome would be mechanically simpler but commonplace. Closed at night and in winter, the halves seal by means of two inflatable gaskets at the interface rims. The facility then converts for expositions, conferences, tennis courts, basketball court, skating rink, jogging track, even an auditorium for public hearings on use of the waterfront. Beautiful year-round multi-use is the key. The view from the stage is south-southeast, taking in some lake but shaded [in summer] from the fierce late sun that waterfront residents know. Tricky engineering, entailing design compromises, but this is a practical proposal, I think, ripe for an architect with authoritative attention to detail. Fred G. Hill

 

A Moran Plant Proposal (excerpt). As noted in the website text, the LCCSC is a respectful, appropriate and exciting current use for the Moran site and should be retained and supported in any design. This proposal would honor that. The balance of the concept would support two additional functions:

1. An elevated, glazed, energy efficient greenhouse structure offering a retreat for enjoyment of the broad visual landscape while providing shelter from the elements. The interior setting would be in fact a botanical garden with live plant matter integrated into public seating areas. Other amenities such as small informative display panels about the genesis of the lake and surrounding topography could be woven into the design. Broad, spectacular views of the western lakeshore as well as the Burlington waterfront and its surrounds would, however, prevail. Environmentally sensitive energy and thermal technology would be employed to yield sufficient heat in the winter months to allow year round use. Inside temperatures would be maintained at moderate heating levels above freezing but not at “living room” temperatures. Plant life could be forthcoming all year. Glazing, while not filling every void, would dominate the design giving the new structure transparency and a respectful impact upon the landscape. A place to enjoy the serenity of Lake Champlain.

2. A small, planetarium would be integrated into the design. Elevated above the tree height, its viewing area would be relatively unobstructed. Operated in conjunction with the Burlington school system, it could provide a rich educational resource destination for field trips and extra curricular activities. Cooperative programs could be developed between the Echo center and the Planetarium. Access would be free to local school families but visitors and those without children in school would be charged, making it self-sustaining and a possibly even a revenue producing amenity.

 

Gentlefolk . . . I trust that included in the choices presented to the public in March will be “None of the Above”. While many people are convinced by and committed to many different ideas, I have no doubt that none of them will come close to receiving even a third of the votes; and that in Instant Runoff Voting “None of the Above” will be a landslide winner. This does not mean doing nothing. The area around the plant can and must be cleaned up. This can be done via a Moran Green Up Day, with volunteer T-shirts designed by some local artist and local bands donating concert time (times they play could be listed in advance). The city could provide tools, bags, work gloves, and water. There must be a way to take care of insurance problems, as green-up days are common. Of course, the city would first have to decide what it hasn’t yet; whether the wild area is to be kept wild for animals (and, apparently, homeless humans), used as a wetland, or grassed over. But something has to be done. At least light it; as of now, women are afraid of walking there at night.

The building itself could be removed from eyesore status by simply sandblasting and doing a basic cheap job of painting the girders to cover graffiti and rust; slopped paint would simply fall on the ground. Serious scraping can be put off until an idea that the city as a whole likes presents itself. And the sandblasting would be cheap because there are no windows to protect; in fact, the interest we don’t pay on any large project for the time until we do do something would probably cover the cost.

The plant itself, thus cleaned up and worked around and lighted, would no longer be an eyesore or keep people from wanting to pass it. It’s the kind of ugly that eventually becomes rather endearing. And when the right idea for it comes, the people of the city will recognize it. Eugene Sapadin

 

I would like to propose that the Moran Plant be converted to a Museum of Burlington Demography, open year round for local folks and tourists to enjoy and learn from. Our city has a fascinating background, a long and interesting diorama of immigration and emigration. I suggest a documentary display of this history in a setting where each of the major ethnic groups that built Burlington could be featured in respective rooms exhibiting the following historic local communities: French-Canadian Burlingtonians, Irish Burlingtonians, German Burlingtonians, Italian Burlingtonians, Welsh/English/Scots Burlingtonians, Jewish Burlingtonians,, Underground Railroad Burlingtionians and with additional areas for our more recent immigrants: Bosnian, Sudanese, Vietnamese, etc.

Each “older” area could demonstrate the little ethnic neighborhoods established in Burlington originally, as well as more recently established “ethnic” areas. For example, from our own family’s background: “Little Jerusalem” centered in the Old North End around Wheeler School in the late 1800’s with its kosher butchers, three synagogues, all in the Archibald Street area.

The data on Burlington history can be retrieved from many sources including the UVM archives (note “We Americans” a thesis by a UVM grad student in the 1940’s). The material is available, as well as the Burlingtonians who can tell the tales. Such a facility would be of great pride to “Old Burlingtonians”, or great interest to those who “came later”, and an inspiration to “newcomers” and those yet to come. One could envision changing exhibits, lectures and demonstrations as part of the museum. It would offer an ongoing memorial to all of us, to the city we have built and continue to build, and a captivating view of who we are, for anyone who takes a glimpse of our hometown. Susanne A. London

 

Dear Mayor Peter Clavelle, I am an inmate at Chittenden Community Regional Facility and my name is Frank Mikan. . . I had an idea or proposal and a solution for the Moran Plant. Why does it not get turned into a prison. What is the difference if it is on the waterfront or in a densely populated community. I would think it would be safer in a place where there is not a lot of people all the time all year long. But with these days security in prison there should not be a problem or an issue with having the Moran Plant as a new prison facility for the City of Burlington, the largest city in Vermont I remind you and not in another town. That being the community of South Burlington. I do not think this should be an issue for the city I would think it would be a no-brainer with all the failed proposals that have come and gone for this site. Or is the issue for the city a money issue and not a community safety issue. I would love to hear what your response to this is; to these ideas and these questions. Frank Milkan P.S. Yes, I’m an inmate but also still a concerned citizen when it comes to the issues of safety as opposed to the revenue of the city. I think there are more safety concern and issues to be addressed than worry or obsessing about the YMCA. Think man! How will all those tourists know that that’s a prison if you don’t tell them and why do they need to know?

 

Tear down. Casino. Y at Memorial or Kmart. Ken Vachereau

 

We also would like the city’s place to do the parking and upgrade the one way road (WMCA)—for this. Also, purchase the remodeling plans from the Y and use it to refurbish. Boat dockage for out of towners near water is a must. #2. All children-families playground should start looking at the Battery and Ethan Allen park for their use—the same way they were back in the 40’s and 50’s. Also a telescope (like once in Battery Park) for public use for the Moran Plant is a must. #3. Two levels of Bed and Breakfast could really attract out of staters and towners via boat, train, bus an easy access for weekends, etc.

CEDO Moran Planning Committee. Why the big hurry to develop the Moran plant right now? If a majority of the city really want a particular development, fine. But in an Instant Runoff format, you must include “None of the Above,” with an understanding that that includes cleaning it up, while waiting for an idea that the city can truly get behind. If not, a majority of the city will almost certainly feel that they were forced to choose something from a list of options none of which they want. Helen Coolidge

 

Get Maritime Museum at Moran. Carolyn Bates

 

Hello. I submitted this photo idea to the City Hall years ago—and I’ll do it again now. First of all the building and the surrounding land should be public . . .for everyone! It should be a place that Vermonters and visitors could enjoy. I envision community boat use in the lake side (west) lower level. Entry and event calendar near the front (east). Community classrooms in the “mid” level with theater space as well. The top floor with the large windows could be an art gallery. Vermont artist and rotating exhibits. The south facing deck space could be for sitting outside, protected from the North Wind). Some refreshments offered and also it could be another program space . . . such as dance or musical groups . . . outside. What a fun place to go! Always something of interest for all ages. A Vermont seed company might be willing to plant wild flowers in the area . . . in exchange for their advertising. A few benches down by the lake would be nice too and a few walking paths and maples ??. Thank you. Liv Seeman

Civic Arts Center

 

Civic Arts Center East Front Entrance

Civic Arts Center Southwest Side

 

 

 

I hope that the Moran Plant will be torn down. The Sailing Center should remain at the site and the Sculpture Garden should be cared for and enhanced. Thank you for asking for community input. Barbara Wright

 

Keep Moran plant part of historical waterfront. Ray Tylicki

 

 


 


 


 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

 

Page last updated July 28, 2005

Burlington, Vermont
 City Hall
Burlington City Hall, 149 Church Street, Burlington, Vermont 05401 2007 City of Burlington, Vermont